PDA

View Full Version : Goh Chok Tong and Tan Cheng Bock to join forces and ‘do a Mah


nitecrawllerr
23-05-2018, 01:40 PM
Emeritus Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong’s latest Facebook post has caused Singaporeans to express their desire to see the former head of government stand against the ruling party in the next election, the same way Malaysian leader Dr Mahathir left his party to unite the opposition across the causeway and topple the government.

This, after ESM Goh posted photos from his 77th birthday bash. Sharing a photo with veteran politician Dr Tan Cheng Bock who attended his exclusive party, Goh alluded to Mahathir’s stunning election victory and said: “Age is just a number, as Mahathir has proven. But it is family and friends who make that number light, meaningful and memorable. Thanks, all my friends out there.”

92-year-old Dr Mahathir Mohamad made history by defeating the incumbent at the polls and ushering in Malaysia’s first transition of power since independence, at the watershed 2018 Malaysian General Election.

Dr Mahathir, who helped establish the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition in power and served as Malaysia’s longest-serving Prime Minister, stepped out of retirement and left the ruling party to lead the opposition. Breaking the BN’s six-decade long monopoly, Dr Mahathir beat his one-time protégé Najib Razak and became the world’s oldest head of government earlier this month.

When news of Dr Mahathir’s victory broke, ESM Goh congratulated the veteran politician and drew parallels between Dr Mahathir and Singapore’s founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew

ESM Goh’s post congratulating Dr Mahathir and his latest post touching on how Dr Mahathir has proven age is just a number come a few months after an exchange between ESM Goh and Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong led netizens to speculate that an internal conflict may be brewing between the pair.

The exchange between the top politicians began on New Year’s Eve when ESM Goh urged the younger minister to select the next Prime Minister ideally within 6-9 months time, calling this an “urgent challenge” for the nation.

Later in January, the Prime Minister commented on ESM Goh’s remarks and said that leadership succession will “take a little bit longer” than what ESM Goh had hoped. He added, in what appeared to be a pointed comment, that “ESM (Goh) is speaking with the privilege of watching things rather than being responsible to make it happen. I think we know it’s a very serious matter.”

In response, the ESM took to Facebook and posted a comment that appeared to throw subtle shade at the PM’s “watching things” comment.

Posting about his meeting with former Iranian Minister of Economic Affairs and Finance, Dr Ali Tayebnia, the former PM said: “I recalled my two visits to Iran fondly, the first as Prime Minister and the second, as Senior Minister. Both of us now ‘watch’ things happen, and coincidentally share a common title. He serves as Senior Advisor to his President while I serve as Senior Advisor to MAS!”

ESM Goh made a similar reference to the “watching” comment in a subsequent post. Uploading two photos, one of himself and another of an unidentified man, the ESM wrote: “I watch as he ruminates in the calmness of Learning Forest, far from the maddening crowd.”

A few hours later, the PM finally responded by sharing ESM Goh’s post and wrote: “‘Watching’ MParader’s posts: Touché! 🙂 – LHL”

Netizens responding to the unusual exchange appear to largely feel that there is some sort of strain in the relationship between the nation’s current and immediate past Prime Ministers.

One netizen wrote, “Using FB to get a message across between a former PM and the current PM reflects a strained relationship that requires some patching up. Hopefully, we don’t end up watching more things happening,” while others have criticised the leaders for being “childish”:

ESM Goh’s posts touching on Dr Mahathir’s success have caused netizens to call on him to ‘do a Mahathir’ and join the opposition camp to fight the incumbent. Both men share similarities, having been Prime Ministers of their respective nations in the past. At 77, ESM Goh is 15 years junior to Dr Mahathir as well.

These calls come after Dr Mahathir’s historic win prompted many Singaporeans to express their desire for Dr Tan Cheng Bock to achieve something similar by contesting the next election from the opposition’s camp:

The inclusion of a photo with Dr Tan in ESM Goh’s latest Facebook post have prompted many Singaporeans to call on ESM Goh to join forces with Dr Tan to achieve a win against the ruling party.

Both Dr Tan and ESM Goh have been noted to be close. In 2014, ESM Goh underwent a major surgery and Dr Tan was one of just three visitors who were permitted to see the ESM apart from his immediate family.

Describing Dr Tan as a “very close friend”, ESM Goh later wrote on Facebook: “I also had an almost hour-long chat with Tan Cheng Bock, my very close friend from school. We talked about mutual friends, health issues and families. Thanks, Bock. I am glad to see you in good health and keeping yourself busy.”

In one of his most recent comments about Dr Tan, ESM Goh had said when Dr Tan announced his intention to contest the last Presidential Election that Dr Tan’s decision to announce his bid for presidency before the election can be seen as a “calculated political gambit” that is open to interpretation.

ESM Goh had said then, in 2016, that Dr Tan – who had lost the 2011 Presidential Election by just over 0.3 per cent of votes – was perhaps politicising the process by announcing his intention to contest the 2017 presidential race as a Constitutional Commission was reviewing the eligibility criteria for candidates at the time.

Speaking to reporters then, ESM Goh said: “His move was a calculated political gambit and, of course, it is open to many interpretations or even misinterpretations. One could interpret his move as coming from someone who is ambitious, as making a move to be president, or it could be to discourage others from coming in.

“Last time, there were four candidates and he nearly won, (he) lost by a small margin. So if you can discourage others from coming in, it’s a straight fight, then you will have a better chance.”
He added that another view could be that his friend could be “rallying the ground to support him”. He said: “Once the ground supports him, it may make it more difficult, he thinks, for the Constitutional Commission to come up with criteria that may disqualify him. This is speculative, of course.”

ESM Goh added: “I know how the Government thinks, we plan ahead to ensure there will be a stable, fair and contestable system that will stand Singapore in good stead. And the system must enable good candidates to contest for president.

“But the commission is still reviewing the process. By coming out now and risking being misunderstood that you are trying to influence the commission’s working, in a way, he has been politicising the process.”

Interestingly, ESM Goh also reaffirmed his friendship with Dr Tan during the same interview and said that he was not surprised by Dr Tan’s announcement: “Indeed, he is an old friend. I’ve known him for over 55 years. What he did was in keeping with his character. Once he has decided to do something, (he) will do all he can to achieve that goal.”

“In the past, we would have spoken to one another. But after the last presidential election, he was and will be on his own.

“We are still very good friends, still go out with each other, but I will not try to influence him…I will just wish him good luck.”

Despite ESM Goh’s assertion that Dr Tan “will be on his own” after the 2011 Presidential Election, Dr Tan’s appearance at ESM Goh’s intimate 77th birthday party has turned heads.

Netizens are now calling on the two politicians to put aside their differences and come together for the good of the nation, like Mahathir did with opposition coalition partners across the causeway:

http://theindependent.sg/singaporeans-clamor-for-goh-chok-tong-and-tan-cheng-bock-to-join-forces-and-to-do-a-mahathir/


Will Tan cb and Woody join forces as opposition party next GE?:D

TheIdesOfMarch
23-05-2018, 01:53 PM
Problem with this whole idea is who the hell are they both going to join?? I can't see them campaigning for any party other than PAP. And if they try to start up a new party they'd be a spoiler force creating three way fights more than anything else.

Malaysia happened because the opposition parties banded together in a coalition. I can hardly see this happening in SG.

denque
23-05-2018, 02:08 PM
Lao Goh. where is our Swiss standard of living you promised?

nitecrawllerr
23-05-2018, 02:08 PM
Indeed. We need heavyweights from present PAP party to jump ship. Only these Goh and Tan to fight Goliath?:D

moonluck
23-05-2018, 02:15 PM
Indeed. We need heavyweights from present PAP party to jump ship. Only these Goh and Tan to fight Goliath?:D

Once the tree fall, those monkeys will disperse :D

nitecrawllerr
23-05-2018, 03:45 PM
PUTRAJAYA: Malaysia will cut the salaries of its Cabinet ministers by 10 per cent with immediate effect, Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad announced on Wednesday (May 23).

"This shows that we are paying attention to the financial problems of the country," he said.

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/malaysian-ministers-salaries-cut-mahathir-hsr-10260126


Will LHL suggest pay cut for all Ministers too?:rolleyes:

escobar43535
23-05-2018, 05:09 PM
Pipe dream!

GCT will not turn against the Lee family because he has tied his boats to them to the very end.

38, Oxley Road saga was GCT's time to stand up and be counted but he acted just as I thought he would, not to rock the boat and keep the status quo in check.

NotMyPresident
23-05-2018, 07:05 PM
Problem with this whole idea is who the hell are they both going to join?? I can't see them campaigning for any party other than PAP. And if they try to start up a new party they'd be a spoiler force creating three way fights more than anything else.

Malaysia happened because the opposition parties banded together in a coalition. I can hardly see this happening in SG.

If people do really care about the state of Singapore which we are in I am sure they will put aside their differences and work together for the common good of their fellow Singaporeans . Having said that Lau Goh will never betray PAP so this is likely not to happen as he still want to enjoy his million dollar salary. The Malaysians show Singaporeans that they have the guts to vote for the opposition. But do Singaporeans dare ?

mellong
23-05-2018, 07:25 PM
PUTRAJAYA: Malaysia will cut the salaries of its Cabinet ministers by 10 per cent with immediate effect, Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad announced on Wednesday (May 23).

"This shows that we are paying attention to the financial problems of the country," he said.

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/malaysian-ministers-salaries-cut-mahathir-hsr-10260126


Will LHL suggest pay cut for all Ministers too?:rolleyes:

He never increase we happy liao, dare not hope for pay cut

ilovepantyhose
23-05-2018, 10:26 PM
Lao Goh. where is our Swiss standard of living you promised?

"swiss" cost of living... :(

Rodontan
23-05-2018, 10:28 PM
You want seat warmer to fight crown prince? How can?

tiahborlang
24-05-2018, 07:23 AM
I don't think Goh Chok Tong will fight against PAP.

If he really wanted to fight PAP, then he must join force with Tan Jee Say and Tan Cheng Bock.

Dr M and Anwar last time were enemies, now they are 'friends'

Will Goh Chok Tong forgive Tan Jee Say and join force with him to topple PAP?

No, he won't dare.

BlueDemon
24-05-2018, 09:15 AM
I feel for Lau Goh. I do not think LHL valued Lau Goh as much as LKY. Also LHL has done little to our country other than building his own team. There are many frictions inside PAP. It would be interesting to see how PAP evolves. If Lau Goh really goes against PAP, it will be very interesting.

TommyPingPong
24-05-2018, 10:27 AM
You people read too much over the birthday party...... If we are so anti PAP, you will vote any opp parties that appear! Vote Han HH! Vote Desmond Lim! SDP Dr Chee will be in parliament by now! But the past 2 results had spoken about the lack of balls of Singaporeans. All just worried lossing the upgrading or the promised park or hawker centers if vote for PAP (which is no true in WP case where the WP estates are also eligible for upgrading from HDB) but end of day after knowing PAP will increase population to 6.9 or more, will still vote PAP next GE................

Some worried their Vietnamese wife cannot get her Social visit pass renewed.... Some are civil servants like teachers, SAF or MHA regulars etc, But hey wait! you are too insignificant for them to track your vote! Wake up!

nitecrawllerr
24-05-2018, 11:02 AM
Once the tree fall, those monkeys will disperse :D

The tree has been around since 1959 GE. 59 years. Age and decay leow.:D

nitecrawllerr
24-05-2018, 11:05 AM
Some are civil servants like teachers, SAF or MHA regulars etc, But hey wait! you are too insignificant for them to track your vote! Wake up!

I wonder why WP didnt highlight to the crowd during their last GE rallies voting is secret. No way their master can track them (civil servants). :D

mongkokbitch
24-05-2018, 12:43 PM
The tree has been around since 1959 GE. 59 years. Age and decay leow.:D

Time to remove those new trees too :D

skyleon
24-05-2018, 01:28 PM
A Singapore’s “Alliance of Hope”: No, not with Goh Chok Tong

Published on 2018-05-24 by The Online Citizen


by Law Kim Hwee

Based on Facebook posts, there appear to be Singaporeans who are wishful of Former Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong doing a "Dr Mahathir" for Singaporeans to stand against the current People's Action Party in the next General Election due by 15 Jan 2021.

Let me state upfront: No! Not with Goh in the Dr Mahathir role.

It's an insult to Dr Mahathir's political charisma and recent tumultuous GE accomplishment to compare wooden (Lee Kuan Yew's adjective) Goh with him.

What do Dr Mahathir and Goh share in common that some think the latter can bring about a "new dawn" for Singapore? Two main ones, namely;

One, both share membership links with the dominant ruling political parties in their respective countries.


Two, both Dr Mahathir and Goh rose to be PMs.

Beyond the above, they diverge dramatically. And in the following key divergences lie the foundational differences that disqualify Goh for a similar Dr Mahathir role in Singapore politics:

– Dr Mahathir was always a maverick, one with a cause - and the courage. As a young politician, he penned "The Malay Dilemma", laying bare publicly his honest, uncomplimentary thoughts about "the behaviour of his own people..." Whilst Goh, from his words and actions, was, has been since resigning from cabinet, is always a PAP man. So, Dr Mahathir, a maverick. Goh, a PAP apparatchik, one of a very, very small handful enjoying his ex-ministerial multimillion $ pension.

– Dr Mahathir speaks his mind clearly, openly. Goh tries too darn hard to be sagely, with his philosophistry, his touches of ambiguous Facebook musings and posts on matters political. You know where Dr Mahathir is coming from and, as important, where he is heading. Goh, with his self-serving ambiguities, appears to hedge his bets in order to lean where the winds of change may blow - and then will he bet his place, maybe. If Dr Mahathir has been compared to a snake. Then he's a straight-shooting one. And the Malays, Indians and Chinese came out to curl around him because they all knew his yes is yes, his no, no.

– Dr Mahathir was branded a dictator and called all kinds of defamatory names. But he "never sued anybody". Says he, "the way of democracy...and in politics, of course, people will call you nasty names. That is normal." But Goh sued Tang Liang Hong, Chee Soon Juan, the New York Times etc... for libel. But when it came time for his PAP's colleague Loong, he lent total support to Lee's abuse of Parliament to try to clear the libellous "dishonourable" honorific that the latter's sister bestowed on him, instead of going to court.

The above three differences are not exhaustive. But they tell us that Goh has not Dr Mahathir's political DNA in the seminal role required to bring about "a new dawn" for Singapore politics.

Now, let me remind Singaporeans how Goh Chok Tong gave or laid the foundations for many of what is presently wrong in Singapore;

– It was Goh who started the "asset enhancement" policy, forcing citizens to use an inordinate amount of their hard-earned savings into HDB (and also 99-year condos), depleting our retirement nest egg while filling up the state's coffers (some of which the PAP use to pay Temasek and GIC cronies million$ in salaries/bonuses with our direct/indirect CPF monies - with zero transparency or accountability).

– It was Goh who started the "mild India fever", the base policy Lee Hsien Loong replicated resulting in the Indian, Chinese, Filipinos, Westerners deluge. Many senior, middle-aged, middle-income Singaporeans are now either unemployed or under-employed, being the collateral damage of the sold-as-mild-but-secretly-executed-as-high fever of Foreign so-called Talents policy.

– Goh called Tan Cheng Bock a "close friend from school" but Bock, "after the last presidential election, he was and will be on his own". By the way, Goh voiced nary a word; neither against the rushed-through for-Malay only Presidential Election legislation nor Halimah's Indian paternal ancestry. Goh is a PAP apparatchik like no other. He probably would prefer Bock banished than his PAP lose overwhelming control.


continue reading here : https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2018/05/24/a-singapores-alliance-of-hope-no-not-with-goh-chok-tong/


You sure you want Lau Goh to defect to the opposition ?

HonkyTonkyMan
24-05-2018, 02:08 PM
I wonder why WP didnt highlight to the crowd during their last GE rallies voting is secret. No way their master can track them (civil servants). :D

voting slip has serial number on it, they say it to prevent cheating but if they want to track it can be done...not that I am saying they will but last time presidential election, know someone kena warning from Election Dept just becos he wrote some F word on the slip...was send a letter to advise him to respect the office being elected...but that being said...didn't stop me from voting for the oppies..

nitecrawllerr
24-05-2018, 03:58 PM
voting slip has serial number on it, they say it to prevent cheating but if they want to track it can be done..

It has to be 100% secret. If not WP should be making lots of noise.

ilovepantyhose
24-05-2018, 05:54 PM
voting slip has serial number on it, they say it to prevent cheating but if they want to track it can be done...not that I am saying they will but last time presidential election, know someone kena warning from Election Dept just becos he wrote some F word on the slip...was send a letter to advise him to respect the office being elected...but that being said...didn't stop me from voting for the oppies..

the ruling party can retain power by gerrymandering. arbo why the boundaries are redrawn?? ;):rolleyes:

NotMyPresident
24-05-2018, 07:04 PM
I wonder if you guys have noticed that the current PAP government has made the biggest blunder in its foreign policy and that it failed to anticipate that there will be a change in the Malaysian government . Singapore current foreign minister should be sacked . :D

Romelu
24-05-2018, 08:00 PM
I wonder if you guys have noticed that the current PAP government has made the biggest blunder in its foreign policy and that it failed to anticipate that there will be a change in the Malaysian government . Singapore current foreign minister should be sacked . :D

Ask Georgie boy to come back ? :D

nitecrawllerr
24-05-2018, 10:33 PM
Ask Georgie boy to come back ? :D

This chap is good. Aljunied loss was a great blow to ruling party.:D

Baigonggong
25-05-2018, 01:28 PM
I wonder if you guys have noticed that the current PAP government has made the biggest blunder in its foreign policy and that it failed to anticipate that there will be a change in the Malaysian government . Singapore current foreign minister should be sacked . :D

Yes really a big blunder . :p

winphenom
26-05-2018, 01:49 AM
The best team would be to get Lee Hsien Yang to team up with the others to form an opposition to contest PAP. That would definitely be a real spectacle and send shivers down all the ruling party's members, especially LHL and his family.... Haha. Maybe more dark secrets would then be revealed....
After all, his father also felt LHY is a better political person and more suited than LHL for his position.